Secret Pizza

If you’ve been searching for an authentic New York-style slice in Los Angeles, your hunt ends at Secret Pizza in Montecito Heights. This unassuming pickup-only operation, run by a dedicated New Jersey transplant, has quietly become one of the city’s most coveted pizza destinations. It’s the kind of spot that makes East Coasters feel right at home and converts West Coasters into true believers.

The pizza here speaks for itself with remarkable simplicity. Each slice delivers that satisfying crunch when you fold it, while the edges remain soft and pillowy—never harsh enough to scrape the roof of your mouth. The foundation is a perfectly balanced tomato sauce with subtle sweetness and a hint of acidity, topped with fresh mozzarella that melts into every bite. While pepperoni is available, the cheese slice is so well-executed that additional toppings feel almost unnecessary.

This is a one-man operation, so expect the care and attention that comes with a passionate solo proprietor. Ordering is straightforward—just follow the link in their Instagram bio to pre-order your pies. There’s a small patio out front if you can’t wait to dig in, which most people can’t once they catch that aroma.

For anyone craving legitimate East Coast pizza without booking a flight, Secret Pizza delivers exactly what its name promises: a hidden gem that rivals the best slice joints in New York and New Jersey. Come hungry, order ahead, and prepare to be impressed.