Arrigo's

Tucked away on Fresh Pond Road in Ridgewood, Arrigo’s is one of those neighborhood gems that pulls double duty with impressive results. By day, it operates as a classic Italian deli slinging carefully crafted sandwiches. Once the sun goes down, the space transforms into an intimate restaurant serving small plates and pastas. It’s a sister spot to Daphne’s, and the family resemblance shows in the attention to quality.

The sandwich menu here takes a quality-over-quantity approach—just seven options during daytime hours, but each one is thoughtfully constructed. The cold sandwiches are particularly noteworthy, especially the turkey deluxe. This substantial creation arrives gloriously messy, with pickle juice mingling with mustard aioli and a kick of horseradish that cuts through the richness. It’s the kind of sandwich that demands napkins and rewards every bite.

The space itself adds to the appeal. Classic checkered floors set the scene, and during the day, natural light fills the room, making it an inviting spot to linger over lunch. When evening arrives, the mood shifts completely—candles flicker and low-hanging lamps create an intimate atmosphere that feels worlds away from the bustling deli vibe of daytime service.

Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch to go or settling in for a leisurely dinner, Arrigo’s delivers that authentic neighborhood Italian experience that’s becoming increasingly hard to find. It’s the kind of place where you can stop by weekly and feel right at home.